To What Extent is Immediate Constituency Analysis Dependency-Based? A Survey of Foundational Texts
نویسندگان
چکیده
This paper investigates the seminal texts on Immediate Constituent Analysis and the associated diagrams. We show that the relations between the whole and its parts, that are typical of current phrase structure trees, were less prominent in the early diagramming efforts than the relationships between units of the same level. This can be observed until the beginning of the 1960’s, including in Chomsky’s Syntactic Structures (1957). We discuss whether such analyses could be said “dependencybased”, according to an attempt to define this term.
منابع مشابه
تبدیل خودکار درختبانک وابستگی فارسی به درختبانک سازهای
There are two major types of treebanks: dependency-based and constituency-based. Both of them have applications in natural language processing and computational linguistics. Several dependency treebanks have been developed for Persian. However, there is no available big size constituency treebank for this language. In this paper, we aim to propose an algorithm for automatic conversion of a depe...
متن کاملContrastive Analysis of Metadiscourse Markers Used by Non-native (Iranians) vs. Native (Americans) Speakers in Developing ELT Materials
Metadiscourse is a widely used term in current discourse analysis and language education, referring to an interesting, and relatively new approach to conceptualizing interaction between text producers and their texts and between text producers and users. Despite the growing importance of the term, however, it is often understood in different ways and used to refer to different aspects of langua...
متن کاملHonesty as a Foundational Virtue According to Islamic Mystical Ethics: Introduction and Definition
Honesty in Islamic mystical ethics, at a superficial level, refers to the correspondence between speech, action, and intention and purpose. This application of honesty has been analyzed in depth in mystical ethics, and the analysis has resulted in honesty being considered as the foundation and basis of other virtues from five aspects, from which it can be understood that many of virtues are not...
متن کاملBuilding Corpora for the Development of a Dependency Parser for Spanish Using Maltparser
The present paper details the process followed for creating training and test corpora for a dependency parser generator (Maltparser). The starting point is the Cast3LB corpus, which contains constituency analyses of Spanish texts. These constituency analyses are automatically transformed into dependency analyses. In addition, the empirically and semiautomatically obtention of a set of syntactic...
متن کاملA syntactic-semantic analysis of \"منصوب به نزع خافض\"based on the Holy Quran
One of important issues in the field of implication and aggression is "منصوب به نزع خافض". It is an idiom related to مفعول به "”. By referring to its definition, a syntactic-semantic analysis will be done in this paper. It tries to indicate what is the relationship between word and meaning and to what extent Arabic syntax focu...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2017